JKPSC Prelims 2023
General Studies (Paper 1)
Consider the following Statements:
Answer & Explanation
Click "Check Answer" to reveal
Correct Answer:
Option C —
Statement-I is correct but Statement-II is incorrect.
Analysis of the StatementsStatement I: Defamation as a reasonable restriction (Correct)
While Article 19(1)(a) grants the freedom of speech and expression, it is not absolute. Article 19(2) lists specific "reasonable restrictions," and defamation is explicitly mentioned as one of the grounds upon which the state can limit your speech. You cannot use your freedom of speech to damage another person's reputation.
Statement II: Right to reputation under Article 19 (Incorrect)
This is where the nuance lies. While the right to reputation is indeed a fundamental right, the Supreme Court of India (most notably in Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India) has ruled that the Right to Reputation is a facet of the Right to Life and Personal Liberty under Article 21, not Article 19.
Key Distinction: Article 19 is about Outward Liberties (speaking, moving, assembling), while Article 21 is about Inherent Dignity and the right to a meaningful life.
Answer verified by Quintessence Classes faculty — Karan Nagar, Srinagar.
Try another question from JKPSC JKAS 2023 Prelims
Try another question from General Studies (Paper 1)
More General Studies (Paper 1) questions
From across UPSC, JKPSC, and JKSSB papers — same subject, different years.
German silver is an alloy of
Which among the following statements are correct regarding share market operations?1. Bear is a person who speculates share prices to fal...
Match the following Rajput States with their capitals during Medieval India:
1. Gahadavalas – Kannauj
2. Tomars – Delhi
3. Chauhans – Jai...
Which of the following statements regarding the Indus Valley Civilization (IVC) are correct?i. Scribes were involved in the seal-making p...
The UAE has sent a space probe mission to the Mars named